Fwd: The passing of Hugo Rietveld

From: "Whitfield, Pamela S." <whitfieldps@ornl.gov>

Date: 19 July 2016 18:26:09 GMT+01:00

To: Harry Powell <harry@mrc-lmb.cam.ac.uk>, Gilberto Artioli <gilberto.artioli@unipd.it>, "aoganov@notes.cc.sunysb.edu" <aoganov@notes.cc.sunysb.edu>, "katran@amu.edu.pl" <katran@amu.edu.pl>, "rocha@ua.pt" <rocha@ua.pt>, "branton@byu.edu" <branton@byu.edu>, "Langan, Paul" <langanpa@ornl.gov>, "stuart.batten@sci.monash.edu.au" <stuart.batten@sci.monash.edu.au>, "garrett@ansto.gov.au" <garrett@ansto.gov.au>

Subject: FW: The passing of Hugo Rietveld

FYI

 

I’m passing this along as the Rietveld method has had an impact (in some cases huge) on areas of interest to your commissions. It is really central to many of the modern applications of powder diffraction so this is felt quite deeply by the Commission on Powder Diffraction. As chair it falls to me to coordinate the CPD efforts to mark his life and achievements but some of your members may wish to contribute as well.

 

In the short term a meeting was already organized for the 22^nd September in Amsterdam entitled “The 50th anniversary of Rietveld Refinement and the 100th anniversary of Powder Diffraction” organized by Lambert van Eijck. Hugo was supposed to attend but the celebration inevitably turns more towards a commemoration. In the circumstances the scope of this meeting is likely to expand even further and the organizers would welcome any support they can get, even if it’s just announcing it.

 

Best regards

 

Pam Whitfield

 

Dr Pamela Whitfield MRSC CChem

Instrument Scientist – POWGEN

Spallation Neutron Source

Oak Ridge National Laboratory

PO Box 2008, MS-6475

Oak Ridge, TN 37831-6475

 Tel: (865) 235-2605

Fax: (865) 574-6080

 

Chair: IUCr Commission on Powder Diffraction

 

From: rietveld_l-request@ill.fr [mailto:rietveld_l-request@ill.fr] On Behalf Of Alan Hewat
Sent: Tuesday, July 19, 2016 8:58 AM
To: rietveld_l@ill.fr
Subject: The passing of Hugo Rietveld

 

The passing of Hugo Rietveld, on the 50th anniversary of Rietveld Refinement and the 100th anniversary of Powder Diffraction

 

It is our sad duty to report the death of Hugo Rietveld at the age of 84 after a short illness. He leaves behind his wife, a son and two daughters to whom we extend our heartfelt sympathy on behalf of the more than one thousand members of the Rietveld Mailing List.

 

Hugo was born on the 7 March 1932 in The Hague and migrated to Western Australia with his family, where in 1957 he enrolled at the University of WA at the same time as Brian O’Connor and Syd Hall.  He obtained his Ph.D. under the supervision of Ted Maslen who had studied under Dorothy Hodgkin at Oxford. Hugo pioneered single crystal neutron diffraction at Lucas Heights Sydney with Terry Sabine, and their first paper was published in Nature in 1961. 

 

Clews C J B, Maslen E N, Rietveld H M and Sabine T M (1961) Nature 192 154

“X-Ray and Neutron Diffraction Examination of p-Diphenylbenzene"

 

Hugo's experience with manual data collection and refinement convinced him of the need to computerise such tasks, and at Lucas Heights and the UWA he programmed two of the first IBM-1620 mainframes in Fortran-II. After obtaining his Ph.D. in 1964 with Dorothy Hodgkin as external examiner, (she had received the Nobel Prize for her work on penicillin and vitamin B12), he joined the neutron diffraction group of the Reactor Centrum Nederland in Petten and his interest turned to powder diffraction because large single crystals were not available for the inorganic materials of interest. 

 

The young group at Petten including Bert Loopstra, Bob van Laar and Hugo Rietveld first addressed the problem of overlapping powder reflections by using a relatively long neutron wavelength (2.6 Ĺ) with a pyrolytic graphite filter. This spread out the long d-spacing peaks, allowing more of them to be resolved, and is still a good solution for the magnetic structures in which they were interested. However, for structure refinement many peaks were still unresolved, and the shorter d-spacings needed for high atomic resolution could not even be seen.

 

In a 1966 paper, Hugo already used intensities from overlapping Bragg peaks. Along with others with the same problem, he then tried to fit multiple peaks to overlapping regions, but with limited success. As well, a neutron powder pattern took a whole week to collect, and the local Electrologica-X1 computer was less powerful than the IBM-1620 - and programmed in Algol.  It was there and then that the brilliantly simple but profound idea arose of refining the crystal structure together with the parameters describing the peak positions and profiles all together, as published in the famous 1969 paper.

 

Rietveld H M (1969) Journal of Applied Crystallography 22 65-71 

“A profile refinement method for nuclear and magnetic structures”

 

Hugo distributed his Algol refinement program widely, but very few papers were initially published using the method. Discouraged by the limited funding available for neutron diffraction, he successfully applied to become head of the library department at Petten.

 

One of us (AH), who had also completed his Ph.D. at Lucas Heights in 1970 and who had moved to Harwell, encountered the same problems with neutron diffraction for structural transitions. On the advice of George Bacon, AH visited Hugo in 1971 and brought back Hugo's new Fortran-II version of the profile refinement program. A Harwell version, modified to model the anisotropic vibrations preceding structural transitions, was very successful, both at Harwell and with Brian Fender's students at Oxford, in particular Tony Cheetham and Bob von Dreele. 

 

In 1973, when the UK joined the EEC and AH moved to ILL in Grenoble, another Oxford student (WIFD) performed his first neutron powder experiments on AH's new D1A high resolution diffractometer, where a powder pattern took only one day to collect, and later only one hour. Again this work was very successful, and the number of papers using what Terry Sabine, in 1978, christened the "Rietveld Method" exploded, supported by new computer programs including those of the early Oxford-Grenoble champions Bob von Dreele and Juan Rodriguez-Carvajal. Yet it was not until 1977 that R.A. Young and colleagues applied the method to X-ray powder diffraction, leading to further rapid growth in the number of publications. Thousands of X-ray publications using Rietveld Refinement are now published every year.

 

Perhaps the greatest acknowledgement of Hugo’s work was his receipt of the 1995 Aminoff Prize, awarded by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, Two of us (AH and WIFD), along with Juan Rodriguez-Carvajal and Ivar Olovsson, were there to witness Hugo, accompanied by his wife and children, receive his accolade from the King of Sweden with typical modesty, delight and genuine astonishment at the pervasive influence of his Method across the sciences around the world. And beyond the world - in December 2012 he was thrilled to receive an e-mail from David Blake of the CheMin team of the Mars Science Laboratory rover, Curiosity, who wrote saying that he did not think they could have convinced NASA to send an X-ray powder diffractometer to Mars without the Rietveld Method.   

 

After almost 50 years, the Rietveld Method has returned to its origins in the Netherlands, with the third of us (LvE) completing a fast new high resolution neutron powder diffractometer (PEARL) on the Delft reactor. Hugo Rietveld lived to see that, and last year was the guest of honour at the opening of this new diffractometer. He, who had been honoured throughout the world for his achievement, was honoured in his own country by a new generation working with neutron powder diffraction and Rietveld Refinement.

 

Having achieved all of that, and with a loving family and friends, he will surely rest in peace.

Alan Hewat (AH), Bill David (WIFD) and Lambert van Eijck (LvE) July 2017

______________________________________________

   Dr Alan Hewat, NeutronOptics, Grenoble, FRANCE 

<Alan.Hewat@NeutronOptics.com> +33.476.98.41.68
        http://www.NeutronOptics.com/hewat
______________________________________________

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Please do NOT attach files to the whole list <Alan.Hewat@NeutronOptics.com>
Send commands to <listserv@ill.fr> eg: HELP as the subject with no body text
The Rietveld_L list archive is on http://www.mail-archive.com/rietveld_l@ill.fr/
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++