Discussion List Archives

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [ddlm-group] DDLm aliases (subject changed). .. .

So, to pull it all together, see below.  Please review and see
what I have missed, mistyped  or failed to convert from some
earlier incarnation.  Comments, corrections and suggestions
greatly appreciated.

I have not yet included the type change for _dictionary_xref.format
because I am not sure a single word code would be sufficient
to describe the format of any given dictionary, so for the moment
it is still Text.

   -- HJB

save_definition.xref_code
     _definition.id             '_definition.xref_code'
     _definition.update           2011-01-26
     _definition.class            Attribute
     _description.text
;
      Code identifying the equivalent definition in the dictionary
      referenced by the DICTIONARY_XREF attributes.

      Use of _definition.xref_code is deprecated in favor of
      use of _alias.xref_code
;
     _name.category_id            definition
     _name.object_id              xref_code
     _type.purpose                Identify    
     _type.container              Single
     _type.contents               Code
      save_

save_ALIAS

     _definition.id               alias
     _definition.scope            Category
     _definition.class            List
     _definition.update           2011-01-26
     _description.text
;
      The attributes used to specify the aliased names of definitions.
      Every tag has an implicit alias to itself with a null
      _alias.xref_code to allow use of the primary tag in
      the ALIAS_ENSEMBLE category.
;
     _category.parent_id          ddl_attr
     _category_key.primitive      ['_alias.definition_id',
                                   '_alias.xref_code']
      save_


save_alias.definition_id 
     _definition.id             '_alias.definition_id'
     _definition.class            Attribute
     _definition.update           2006-11-16
     _description.text
;
      Identifier tag of an aliased definition.
;
     _name.category_id            alias
     _name.object_id              definition_id
     _type.purpose                Key    
     _type.container              Single
     _type.contents               Tag
      save_

save_alias.deprecated
     _definition.id             '_alias.deprecated'
     _definition.class            Attribute
     _definition.update           2006-11-16
     _description.text
;
      Specifies whether use of the alias is deprecated
;
     _name.category_id            alias
     _name.object_id              definition_id
     _type.purpose                STATE
     _type.container              Single
     _type.contents               YesorNo
     _enumeration.default         No
      save_


save_alias.dictionary_uri
     _definition.id             '_alias.dictionary_uri'
     _definition.update           2011-01-26
     _definition.class            Attribute
     _description.text
;
      Dictionary URI in which the aliased definition belongs.
      _alias.dictionary_uri is deprecated in favor if
      _alias.xref_code
;
     _name.category_id            alias
     _name.object_id              dictionary_uri
     _type.purpose                Identify    
     _type.container              Single
     _type.contents               Uri
      save_

save_alias.xref_code
     _definition.id             '_alias.xref_code'
     _definition.update           2011-01-26
     _definition.class            Attribute
     _description.text
;
      Code identifying the dictionary containing the primary
      definition of the dictionary as given in the
      DICTIONARY_XREF category.

;
     _name.category_id            definition
     _name.object_id              xref_code
     _name.linked_item_id         '_dictionary_xref.code'
     _type.purpose                Key
     _type.container              Single
     _type.contents               Code
      save_




save_ENSEMBLE

   _definition.id      ensemble
   _definition.scope   Category
   _definition.class   List
   _definition.update  2011-01-26
;
    Data items used to describe the ensemble identifiers
    used in this dictionary.  Data items in this category
    are NOT used as attributes of individual data items.

    See linked item _alias_ensemble.ensemble_id.
;
    _category.parent_id ddl_attr
    _category_key.generic  '_ensemble.id'

    save_

save_ensemble.id
     _definition.id   '_ensemble.id'
     _definition.class  Attribute
     _definition.update 2011-01-26
     _description.text
;
     A code identifying an ensemble of related tags.
     To help ensure that dictionaries can be merged,
     each code should either begin with an IUCr-registered
     prefix or if not prefixed, have been approved
     by COMCIFS.  The special prefix 'local_' may be
     use for purely internal purposes of an organization.
;
     _name.category_id ensemble
     _name.object_id   code
     _type.purpose     Key
     _type.container   Single
     _type.contents    Code

    save_

save_ensemble.description
     _definition.id   '_ensemble.description'
     _definition.class  Attribute
     _definition.update 2011-01-26
     _description.text
;
     A description of the ensemble
;
     _name.category_id ensemble
     _name.object_id   code
     _type.purpose     Describe
     _type.container   Single
     _type.contents    Text


    save_

save_ALIAS_ENSEMBLE

    _definition.id      alias_ensemble
    _definition.scope   Category
    _definition.class   List
    _definition.update  2011-01-26
;
     The attributes used to specify the ensemble of
     tags to which a given tag belong.

     A given tag may belong to multiple ensembles
     and may be cited against multiple dictionaries.

;
    _category.parent_id  alias
    _category.parent_join  Yes
    _category_key.primitive  ['_alias_ensemble.ensemble_id',
                              '_alias_ensemble.definition_id',
                              '_alias_ensemble.xref_code']
     save_

save_alias_ensemble.definition_id
     _definition.id   '_alias_ensemble.definition_id'
     _definition.class  Attribute
     _definition.update 2011-01-21
     _description.text
;
     Identifier tag of a definition associated with
     an xref code by which to group this tag with
     other tags.

     A given tag may belong to multiple ensembles
     and may be cited against multiple dictionaries.

     Note that the tag does not have to be a valid
     tag under DDLm tag construction rules, but
     it should be a valid tag under the rules of
     some DDL.
;
     _name.category_id alias_ensemble
     _name.object_id   definition_id
     _name.linked_item_id  '_alias.definition_id'
     _type.purpose     Key
     _type.container   Single
     _type.contents    Code
      save_

save_alias_ensemble.ensemble_id
     _definition.id   '_alias_ensemble.ensemble_id'
     _definition.class  Attribute
     _definition.update 2011-01-26
     _description.text
;
     A code identifying an ensemble of related tags.
     To help ensure that dictionaries can be merged,
     each code should either begin with an IUCr-registered
     prefix or if not prefixed, have been approved
     by COMCIFS.  The special prefix 'local_' may be
     use for purely internal purposes of an organization.
;
     _name.category_id alias_ensemble
     _name.object_id   code
     _name.linked_item_id  '_ensemble.id'
     _type.purpose     Key
     _type.container   Single
     _type.contents    Code

    save_


save_alias_ensemble.xref_code
     _definition.id   '_alias_ensemble.xref_code'
     _definition.class  Attribute
     _definition.update 2011-01-21
     _description.text
;
     A code identifying the actual dictionary,
     virtual dictionary or other logical grouping
     to which the identifier tag belongs.
;
     _name.category_id alias_ensemble
     _name.object_id   code
     _name.linked_item_id  '_dictionary_xref.code'
     _type.purpose     Key
     _type.container   Single
     _type.contents    Code
      save_




At 2:29 PM -0600 1/26/11, Bollinger, John C wrote:
>On Wednesday, January 26, 2011 11:34 AM, Herbert J. Bernstein wrote:
>
>>OK, so we need to pick a non-conflicting name for the tag that gives
>>the unifying identifier that will satisfy John W.'s concerns and
>>James's concerns, but that will not preclude John B. and David's
>>preference to allow the presentation to be unified with the
>>xref_code.  How about "ensemble_id".  This is a distinct concept
>>from the identifier of the dictionary itself, because one
>>dictionary can contain multiple ensembles and one ensemble
>>can span multiple dictionaries.
>
>Ok, that makes sense.
>
>>  Here is my modified version of John B.' proposal:
>
>I think we are close here.  There are a couple of additions I would 
>like to see to Herbert's version of the proposal, however.  Rather 
>than quote the whole thing, I include it verbatim below, with my 
>additions at the bottom and additional commentary following:
>
>
>1) Deprecate _alias.dictionary_uri.
>
>2) Add as a of subcategory of alias, alias_ensemble with the following
>tags:
>
>_alias_ensemble.definition_id
>      a tag identifier belonging to an ensemble
>_alias_ensemble.ensemble_id
>      a code identifying an ensemble of tags to which the tag belongs
>_alias_ensemble.xref_code
>
>All of these tags are members of the composite key of the sub
>category, so that it is possible to have a physical dictionary
>the same tag in multiple ensembles, or to break out this subcategory
>as a master index running over all tags alias giving both the
>physical dictionaries from which they are taken and and the
>ensembles to which they belong.
>
>3) Add tag
>
>_alias.xref_code
>
>to the alias category
>
>_alias.xref_code specifies the physical dictionary from which the
>preferred definition of the tag alias has been taken, or is null
>if the current dictionary is the primary definer of the tag alias.
>This tag is the parent of _alias_ensemble.xref_code.  There are
>some technical issues on use of the join mechanism, and which
>tags are keys, but they can be resolved if the flattened version
>is truly desired.
>
>
>4) Add tag:
>
>_alias.deprecated: Specifies whether use of the alias is deprecated.
>      _type.purpose     State
>      _type.container   Single
>      _type.contents    YesorNo
>
>5) Modify the definition of _dictionary_xref.format by changing its
>_type.contents attribute to "Code".
>
>6) Deprecate _definition.xref_code (its purpose will be served via
>the alias mechanism)
>
>
>----
>JCB Adds:
>----
>
>7) In the ALIAS category, replace attribute _category_key.generic with:
>     _category_key.primitive [ '_alias.xref_code' '_alias.definition_id' ]
>
>This is still appropriate, inasmuch data names are not guaranteed to 
>be globally unique across all dictionaries.  For that matter, if it 
>were inappropriate here then there would be no need for 
>_alias_ensemble.xref_code, as no _alias.definition_id could be 
>associated with more than one xref_code, and that one would be 
>specified by _alias.xref_code.
>
>
>8) Modify the description of the DICTIONARY_XREF category to: "The 
>DICTIONARY_XREF attributes identify and describe logical or physical 
>dictionaries to which items in the current dictionary are 
>cross-referenced using the _definition.xref_code or _alias.xref_code 
>attribute."
>
>I still think the concept of a logical dictionary is a sound and 
>useful one, even alongside Herbert's _alias_ensemble idea.  This 
>wording change accommodates the concept without requiring any new 
>attributes.  Be it known, however, that if we agree to this then 
>corresponding slight adjustments may be needed to the definitions of 
>some of the other existing attributes in the DICTIONARY_XREF 
>category.  I think those can be discussed later, when and if the 
>time comes.
>
>Naturally, if _definition.xref_code were removed instead of 
>deprecated, then this definition should not refer to it.
>
>========
>
>
>I can live with deprecating _definition.xref_code and 
>_alias.definition_uri, though my preference is still to remove them. 
>Inasmuch as, to my knowledge, DDLm has so far been published and 
>distributed only in draft / for-comments form, it will indeed be a 
>new standard when it eventually is accepted by COMCIFS.  Those 
>developers and dictionary authors already working with the draft 
>should be doing so with the understanding that it is subject to 
>change.  Also, I suspect we will consider further 
>possibly-disruptive changes before we are done, and I am loathe to 
>set a precedent that compatibility with the draft is a supremely 
>compelling concern.
>
>Nevertheless, deprecation vs. removal of these attributes is too 
>small a detail to be hung up over.  When we are ready to vote on the 
>overall proposal, I would prefer to vote separately on that question 
>-- separately for each attribute, in fact.  In the mean time, let's 
>proceed.
>
>Question to consider: should there be a means in the DDL to identify 
>the significance of a particular ensemble, at least for the benefit 
>of humans?  That might take a form as simple as a dictionary-scoped 
>ENSEMBLE category, with attributes _ensemble.ensemble_id and 
>_ensemble.description.
>
>I note also that Herbert did not bring forward my proposed 
>_alias.dictionary_version attribute into his version of the 
>proposal, nor have I added it back to this version.  I see only 
>limited potential use for it, and I am not prepared to argue for it. 
>Others of you may think differently, however.
>
>
>Regards,
>
>John
>
>--
>John C. Bollinger, Ph.D.
>Department of Structural Biology
>St. Jude Children's Research Hospital
>
>
>
>Email Disclaimer:  www.stjude.org/emaildisclaimer
>
>_______________________________________________
>ddlm-group mailing list
>ddlm-group@iucr.org
>http://scripts.iucr.org/mailman/listinfo/ddlm-group


-- 
=====================================================
  Herbert J. Bernstein, Professor of Computer Science
    Dowling College, Kramer Science Center, KSC 121
         Idle Hour Blvd, Oakdale, NY, 11769

                  +1-631-244-3035
                  yaya@dowling.edu
=====================================================
_______________________________________________
ddlm-group mailing list
ddlm-group@iucr.org
http://scripts.iucr.org/mailman/listinfo/ddlm-group

Reply to: [list | sender only]
International Union of Crystallography

Scientific Union Member of the International Council for Science (admitted 1947). Member of CODATA, the ICSU Committee on Data. Member of ICSTI, the International Council for Scientific and Technical Information. Partner with UNESCO, the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization in the International Year of Crystallography 2014.

ICSU Scientific Freedom Policy

The IUCr observes the basic policy of non-discrimination and affirms the right and freedom of scientists to associate in international scientific activity without regard to such factors as ethnic origin, religion, citizenship, language, political stance, gender, sex or age, in accordance with the Statutes of the International Council for Science.